● NZ ELECTION COUNT☀ WEATHER● RADIOAdvertise
DVDOWNUNDERVOICESAustralia · New Zealand · World
Back to Editorial
Editorial

17 November 2026

Opinion: The supermarket advice voters did not see shows we need real competition powers, not election slogans

By Downunder Voices Opinion

Opinion: The supermarket advice voters did not see shows we need real competition powers, not election slogans

Advice to the government found a Foodstuffs split on its own would barely move grocery prices, and it was kept out of public view until shortly before the election. Shoppers deserve a tougher, more honest plan.

Downunder Voices perspective

Full analysis

Grocery prices are one of the biggest worries for New Zealand families, so any plan to fix them deserves an honest public debate. It now appears that voters did not get one.

Advice commissioned by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment from consultancy Coriolis was not a firm endorsement of breaking up the supermarket chains, NZ Herald journalist Jenée Tibshraeny reported, according to the Democracy Project's 17 November briefing. Nicola Willis's office twice turned down the Herald's Official Information Act requests for the advice, and it was released only to a journalist shortly before the election, the briefing said. Meanwhile MBIE published a more favourable analysis by Sense Partners on its own website. Tibshraeny wrote that the handling "feels cynical".

What the advice said

Coriolis has since published a summary of five reports released by MBIE, totalling more than 580 pages. The work began with slides for a meeting with Ms Willis in April 2025 and continued through September 2025.

The findings are sobering. Coriolis estimated that splitting the chains alone would cut prices by about one cent in the dollar, and that its three demerger options would lower consumer prices by 0.5 to 1 per cent. It found "no easy fixes" and singled out attracting a limited-range discounter such as Aldi as the standout opportunity. Business news site B2B News reported on 10 November that the work pointed to biosecurity rules and labour costs as bigger drivers of grocery prices.

Compare that with the campaign. National's 2026 platform promised to split Foodstuffs into two, creating three national chains, and its own modelling claimed prices would be 3.5 per cent lower after one year and 5 per cent lower after six, B2B News reported. Ms Willis put household savings at up to $1,320 a year, B2B News reported.

Why this matters

There is a pattern here worth naming. When advice supports a minister's plan, it goes on the website. When it does not, the public has to fight for it under the Official Information Act. That is not how good government is meant to work, whichever party is in charge.

None of this means the supermarket problem is imaginary. The Commerce Commission's 2022 market study found the sector was not workably competitive, Coriolis noted. Families paying more each week for basics know that already.

What it does mean is that a single headline policy will not fix it. The progressive parties have the better instinct here. The Opportunity Party has made stronger Commerce Commission powers one of its five bottom lines for coalition talks, interest.co.nz's Anna Whyte reported, according to the Democracy Project. That is a sensible bottom line, and Labour and the Greens should back it in any talks.

A credible plan would give the Commerce Commission and the Grocery Commissioner sharper tools, free up land and planning rules so new competitors can actually open stores, actively court a discount chain, and make sure smaller grocers can get fair wholesale access. A break-up can still be on the table, but sold honestly, as one tool among several, not as a promise of big savings that the government's own advice did not support.

The other side

Supporters of the break-up argue that structural change is the only way to end the duopoly for good, and that even a 1 per cent saving adds up across billions of dollars of grocery sales. Ministers can also point out that the Coriolis advice was eventually released, and that the 2022 Sense Partners analysis found a net benefit from divestment over 20 years, according to B2B News. The New Zealand Initiative's Eric Crampton has argued the first step is simply making it easier to build supermarkets.

That last point is one everyone should be able to agree on. Whatever the next government looks like after 27 November, it should publish all the supermarket advice it holds and give shoppers a plan built on the evidence, not on campaign numbers.

This is an opinion column.

Sources: Democracy Project (Bryce Edwards), News Briefing, 17 November 2026 (summarising Jenée Tibshraeny, NZ Herald, and Anna Whyte, interest.co.nz); Coriolis Research, "Restructuring New Zealand's Supermarket Duopoly", November 2026; B2B News, "Coriolis: Foodstuffs split cuts grocery prices only 1-3%", 10 November 2026.

Photo: public-domain photograph via Wikimedia Commons (public domain / CC0), selected by Downunder Voices.

About this report

This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.

Join our community

Follow Downunder Voices

Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.

Read Next

View latest
NZ Election: special votes being counted — result 27 Nov