● NZ ELECTION COUNT☀ WEATHER● RADIOAdvertise
DVDOWNUNDERVOICESAustralia · New Zealand · World
Back to Editorial

Opinion: New Zealand's High Court says the pay equity law discriminated against women. It has to go

By Downunder Voices Opinion

This is opinion, not straight news. Prepared with AI assistance and published under our editorial standards.

Opinion: New Zealand's High Court says the pay equity law discriminated against women. It has to go

A judge has found the 2025 law that cancelled 33 pay equity claims unjustifiably discriminated on the basis of sex, and that saving money was the main driver. Whoever leads next must repeal it and restore a fair process.

Downunder Voices perspective

Full analysis

For eighteen months, the women who care for our sick, teach our children and keep our public services running have been told that their pay equity claims were scrapped for their own good. This week the High Court said otherwise.

In a decision released on 19 November, Justice Paul Radich declared that the Equal Pay Amendment Act, which the National-led government passed under urgency in May 2025, is inconsistent with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, 1News political reporter Justin Hu reported. The judge found that the workers affected had been subject to unjustified discrimination on the basis of their sex.

That is a remarkable finding about a law that was supposed to make pay equity work better. It should change the conversation in every coalition room in Wellington.

What the 2025 law did

The facts are worth setting out plainly, because they were rushed through so quickly that many New Zealanders never saw them.

According to 1News, the law passed all three readings in a single day, with no select committee and no chance for the public to be heard. It cancelled 33 active pay equity claims, many of them years in the making. It raised the test for a female-dominated workforce from 60 per cent to 70 per cent, sustained for at least ten consecutive years. And it limited the comparisons claimants could draw to their own industry or sector.

That last change matters more than it sounds. The whole point of pay equity is to ask whether work done mostly by women has been undervalued compared with work of similar skill and responsibility done mostly by men. If you can only compare within a sector that is already dominated by women, you are measuring an undervalued job against other undervalued jobs. The test becomes much harder to pass, almost by design.

What the court found

Five unions representing health staff, teachers, public servants and tertiary education staff brought the challenge, 1News reported.

Justice Radich looked at the official papers behind the law and found nothing tangible showing that the old system was broken. Instead, he concluded that "the main driver was fiscal". He also found that the changes were not proportionate to their stated objectives.

In plain English: the government said it was fixing a flawed process, but the court found the evidence pointed to saving money, and that the way it did so discriminated against women.

The unions did not win every point. The court found that passing the law under urgency without consultation was lawful, and that cancelling the claims did not breach natural justice. That is important to note, because it shows this was a careful judgment, not a blanket win for one side.

A declaration of inconsistency also does not strike the law down. It stays in force. The Crown can still appeal. If the declaration stands, the Attorney-General must tell Parliament, and the government must give a formal response within six months, 1News reported.

Why this is a test for the next government

So the court has done its job. Now Parliament has to do its job.

The law cannot be quietly left on the books while the next government is formed. A statute that a senior judge has found discriminates against women on the basis of their sex is not a technical problem for officials to manage. It is a matter of basic fairness, and of whether Parliament respects the rights it wrote into law in 1990.

Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori opposed the bill when it passed in May 2025, as the parliamentary record shows. That stand has now been vindicated by the High Court. Any government that Labour leads should commit, in its coalition agreement, to repealing the 2025 changes and restoring a fair pathway for the claims that were cancelled.

The Opportunity Party now holds the balance in many scenarios. According to 1News, it opposed the 2025 changes, but repealing them was not one of its five published bottom lines for coalition talks. The Public Service Association has called on Opportunity to take leadership on the issue and said no coalition deal should leave the law in place.

That is a fair challenge, and Opportunity should take it up. The party prides itself on evidence-based policy. Here is a court ruling that tested the evidence and found it lacking. If Opportunity wants to be the party of good process and honest numbers, it should insist that pay equity is restored in any agreement it signs, whichever side it talks to.

The real cost of "fiscal" decisions

It is worth remembering who sits behind the 33 cancelled claims. They are working people in health, schools, the public service and tertiary education, many of them the workers who held the country together during the pandemic and who are now being asked to do more with less in a stretched public service.

Pay equity is not a pay rise for its own sake. It is a correction for decades in which work done mainly by women was paid less simply because women did it. The previous system, built by consensus across Parliament, was slow and imperfect. But it was producing settlements, including the landmark care and support worker settlement of 2017 under a National-led government. Fixing its flaws was always possible. Scrapping live claims overnight was a choice.

When the court says that choice was driven by money, ordinary voters understand exactly what that means. Budgets were balanced, in part, by deciding that women's work could wait.

What should happen now

First, the caretaker government should not appeal this decision. Spending public money to defend a law that the High Court has found discriminatory, in the dying weeks of a government that may not be returned, would compound the original mistake.

Second, every party in coalition talks should state clearly whether it will repeal or fix the 2025 changes. Voters are entitled to know before any deal is signed.

Third, the next government should restore a proper process, with a full select committee, so that unions, employers and the public can design a pay equity system that is fair and affordable. Done properly, that is the opposite of what happened in May 2025.

The government's case

Outgoing Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden said officials were carefully considering the decision, that the Crown must decide whether to appeal, and that because of that and the caretaker period she would not comment further, 1News reported. When it passed the law, the government argued that the old regime had the wrong settings, that claims were too easy to start and too costly and uncertain for taxpayers, and that the changes would make the system more workable.

Those concerns about cost and process deserve a serious answer. But the right answer was to consult, design and legislate carefully, not to cancel 33 live claims in a day. The court has now said, in effect, that saving money was not a good enough reason to treat women's work unequally.

The next government has six months, at most, to show it agrees.

This is an opinion column.

Sources: 1News (Justin Hu), "Govt's pay equity changes breached women's rights, High Court rules", 19 November 2026; New Zealand Parliament, Equal Pay Amendment Bill votes, May 2025.

Photo: public-domain photograph via Wikimedia Commons (public domain / CC0), selected by Downunder Voices.

About this report

This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.

Join our community

Follow Downunder Voices

Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.

Read Next

View latest
NZ Election: special votes being counted — result 27 Nov