Opinion: More New Zealanders are being charged for low-level drug use. The 2019 promise of help first is being broken
By Downunder Voices Opinion
This is opinion, not straight news. Prepared with AI assistance and published under our editorial standards.
A Drug Foundation report finds low-level drug charges at a ten-year high, with Māori charged at nearly five times the rate of non-Māori. Police should be chasing the gangs, not people caught with a pipe.
Downunder Voices perspective
Full analysis
In 2019, Parliament made a sensible decision. Police were told not to prosecute people for possessing or using drugs unless a prosecution was required in the public interest, and to consider a health-centred response instead. New figures suggest that promise is quietly being broken.
A new report from the NZ Drug Foundation, "Drugs and the Justice System in Aotearoa", built from Ministry of Justice and Police data, found that more people were charged with low-level drug offences in 2025-26 than at any point in the past decade, 1News reported on 20 November.
The numbers
According to the report, 4230 people were charged in 2025-26 with drug possession or use as their most serious drug offence. In 960 cases, possession or use was the only charge. Sixty-two people were convicted solely for having a drug utensil, such as a pipe, the most in five years. Fifteen people were sent to prison for possession or use alone.
The share of cases ending up in court tells the story. After the 2019 law change, court proceedings fell to 18.9 per cent of cases in 2021. By 2025 they had climbed back to 43.2 per cent, higher than before the reform, according to the figures reported by 1News.
The burden is not shared fairly. Māori were charged at 4.8 times the rate of non-Māori and faced 47 per cent of all drug charges, despite making up about 15 per cent of the population aged 15 and over. Māori were more than half of those convicted for possession or use, and nearly 58 per cent of those imprisoned for it.
Young people are caught too. Over the past decade, 943 people under 25 were convicted for possession or use with no other charge.
Why this matters
The Drug Foundation's executive director Sarah Helm put it bluntly: "Punishing people for using drugs does not work – it makes things much worse." A conviction can follow a young person for life, closing doors to jobs, travel and housing, without doing anything to treat addiction.
Ms Helm also pointed to where the money goes. According to the foundation, around $334 million a year is spent on drug law enforcement, twice what is spent on prevention, addiction treatment and harm reduction combined. She noted that three people a week die from preventable accidental overdoses.
To be fair, the rise in court action began before the current government took office. The low point was 2021. But the caretaker government has spent three years promoting a tougher approach to crime, and the signal that sends to the front line is clear. Discretion that leans towards help has gradually given way to discretion that leans towards the courts.
What should change
Labour passed the 2019 reform. The Greens have long called for drug use to be treated as a health issue, and The Opportunity Party has argued for evidence-based drug policy rather than slogans. Together they should make this part of any coalition agreement.
The Drug Foundation's recommendations are a good starting point: remove criminal penalties for low-level possession and use; review the police instructions on the 2019 law and report regularly on how discretion is used; fund more Kaupapa Māori services; expand Te Pae Oranga iwi community panels and the Alcohol and Other Drug Treatment Courts; and move money from low-level enforcement to serious organised crime, treatment and harm reduction.
None of that is soft. It frees police to chase the gangs that profit from the drug trade, instead of processing people caught with a pipe.
The other side
Police see things differently. Detective Superintendent Greg Williams, director of the national organised crime group, told 1News that prosecutions are needed because transnational crime groups and gangs are operating in New Zealand, and that most people charged with possession also face other offences. He said around 8000 people were charged from July 2024 and more than 4000 of them were dealt with outside court. He welcomed expanding treatment courts, but disagreed that all funding should shift to treatment, and said a review should be considered but was hard to justify on one report.
Those are fair points, and police deserve the tools to tackle organised crime. But the figures for people charged with possession or use alone, and the stark overrepresentation of Māori, show the 2019 promise is not being kept. The next government should keep it.
This is an opinion column.
Sources: 1News (River Lin), "More people now being charged with low-level drug offences", 20 November 2026; NZ Drug Foundation, "Drugs and the Justice System in Aotearoa", as reported 20 November 2026.
Photo: public-domain photograph via Wikimedia Commons (public domain / CC0), selected by Downunder Voices.
About this report
This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.
Join our community
Follow Downunder Voices
Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.