● NZ ELECTION COUNT☀ WEATHER● RADIOAdvertise
DVDOWNUNDERVOICESAustralia · New Zealand · World
Back to Editorial
Editorial

15 November 2026

Opinion: Voters still do not know who paid for the 2026 campaign. Fix the donation rules before 2029

By Downunder Voices Opinion

Opinion: Voters still do not know who paid for the 2026 campaign. Fix the donation rules before 2029

Registered campaign groups could each spend $424,000 on election ads without telling anyone where the money came from. Whoever forms the next government should make full donor disclosure a first-year law.

Downunder Voices perspective

Full analysis

New Zealand has voted, the special votes are being counted and the coalition talks are under way. One question has no answer and, under the current law, never will: who paid for the advertising that tried to change our minds?

Political parties have to tell the Electoral Commission who gives them large donations. Groups that campaign alongside the parties do not. That gap was legal in 2026. It should not be legal in 2029.

How the gap works

Any group can register with the Electoral Commission as a "third-party promoter" and campaign for or against parties and policies. In 2026 a registered promoter could spend up to $424,000 on election advertising, The Spinoff reported on 13 November. An unregistered promoter could spend up to $17,000. For comparison, a party's own advertising limit was just over $1.5 million, and each electorate candidate was limited to $36,000.

The catch is on the other side of the ledger. The Electoral Commission's guidance tells third-party promoters they do not need to record or report the donations they receive, the Democracy Project's Bryce Edwards noted in September. They file a spending return only if they spend more than $100,000, The Spinoff reported. So a group can raise hundreds of thousands of dollars, spend it attacking one side, and never say where a cent of it came from.

This is not a small corner of the system. There were 25 registered promoters at this election, Newsroom's Jonathan Milne reported, according to the Democracy Project's summary of his work on 5 November. Each was entitled to spend up to $424,000 without naming its funders.

The groups that campaigned

The best-known is the Taxpayers' Union. It is a registered promoter, and its membership list is confidential unless a supporter chooses to go public, Edwards reported. Its executive director, Jordan Williams, has been open about the group's purpose. The Union's annual review set the aim to "do everything in our power to ensure that Labour does not return to office", Edwards reported.

There is nothing wrong with a lobby group having a political view. Voters, though, deserve to know whose view it is. When a campaign tells you a party's tax plan will wreck the economy, it matters whether the money behind that message came from thousands of small donors or from a handful of people who would pay the tax.

Writing in the Sunday Star Times, Andrea Vance worked out that five like-minded groups, including the Taxpayers' Union, the Free Speech Union, Hobson's Pledge and the Sensible Sentencing Trust, could in theory spend $2.12 million between them, according to the Democracy Project's 15 November briefing. No donor to any of them has to be named.

Online, the picture is murkier still. The Spinoff's analysis of Meta and Google ad data found that Centrist NZ, founded by Canadian Jim Grenon, spent more than $10,000 on Meta ads without being a registered third-party advertiser. TikTok's transparency tool does not even work in New Zealand, the same analysis found, so nobody can check spending there at all.

The parties are not short of money either

The parties themselves raised large sums this cycle. National has taken more than $13.4 million, ACT more than $6.2 million, NZ First more than $3 million and Labour more than $5 million, Newsroom reported, according to the Democracy Project's summary. At least party donations above the threshold are eventually published. The full party spending returns for 2026 are not due until April next year, The Spinoff noted. That means we will learn the details of this campaign's money five months after the votes were counted.

Big money and hidden money are two separate problems, and the second is easier to fix.

What should change

First, every registered third-party promoter should have to disclose donors on the same terms as political parties. Vance has proposed disclosure of donations above $6,000, the Democracy Project reported. That is a sensible starting point.

Second, groups that share staff, offices or directors should share a single spending cap. Otherwise one well-funded network can multiply its limit simply by registering more names.

Third, foreign money should be banned from third-party campaigns as it is from party donations. Vance proposed this too.

Fourth, the online rules need to catch up. Every paid political ad on every platform should carry a clear name and appear in a public library that New Zealanders can search.

None of this is radical. It is the same standard we already apply to parties. Labour, the Greens and the Opportunity Party should make it a shared priority in any talks. Whoever ends up in government after 27 November should pass this in its first year, well before the next campaign starts, so that no party can be accused of changing the rules to suit itself.

It should also cover every side. Unions run third-party campaigns too: the Council of Trade Unions spent $23,800 on Google ads, against the Taxpayers' Union's $25,800, The Spinoff found. Rules that ask the left to open its books along with the right are a feature, not a cost. We are confident progressive campaigns can live with them.

The other side

Defenders of the current rules make reasonable points. Third-party campaigning is a form of free speech, and groups argue that naming donors could expose ordinary supporters to harassment. Mr Williams has said that about two-thirds of the Taxpayers' Union's money comes from small online donations and less than 3 per cent from industry, Edwards reported. Others argue the spending caps already limit any one group's reach, and that tougher rules would mostly add paperwork for small community campaigns.

Those concerns can be met. A disclosure threshold of several thousand dollars protects small donors, and caps already keep the amounts in check. What cannot be defended is a system where the people with the deepest pockets can shape an election in private.

The 2026 election was close, and the final result may still turn on the special votes. In a contest that tight, every hidden dollar matters. The next Parliament has three years to make sure that in 2029, voters know who is talking to them.

This is an opinion column.

Sources: The Spinoff (Shanti Mathias), 13 November 2026; Democracy Project (Bryce Edwards), "The influence of the Taxpayers' Union in the election", 22 September 2026; Democracy Project News Briefing, 5 November 2026 (summarising Newsroom reporting by Jonathan Milne); Democracy Project News Briefing, 15 November 2026 (summarising Andrea Vance, Sunday Star Times); Electoral Commission third-party promoter guidance, 2026.

Photo: Bowen House, the Beehive and Parliament House, Wellington, by Midnighttonight via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0).

About this report

This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.

Join our community

Follow Downunder Voices

Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.

Read Next

View latest
Source: The Loadstar

17 November 2026

Gemini carriers target complete return to Suez transits by mid-January

Gemini Cooperation partners Maersk and Hapag-Lloyd will have made a full resumption of Suez transits on their Asia-Europe services by mid-January. Yesterday, the partners outlined the schedule for the last three Asia-North Europe services still detouring via the Cape of Good Hope to return to the Red Sea routing. The Asia-Northern Europe Loop 1 (Maersk AE2/Hapag-Lloyd NE1) will resume Suez transits in both directions with the departure of the 18,300 teu Mary ...

The LoadstarRead original
NZ Election: special votes being counted — result 27 Nov