Opinion: An 11-seat overhang has pushed Parliament to 131 MPs. Fix MMP's weak spot before 2029, not after
By Downunder Voices Opinion
This is opinion, not straight news. Prepared with AI assistance and published under our editorial standards.
Forty-six electoral experts say the overhang now threatens the proportional heart of MMP. Labour, the Greens and Opportunity should make a fair, cross-party fix a condition of the next government, and National should stop hiding behind a routine review.
Downunder Voices perspective
Full analysis
New Zealanders voted for proportional representation three times: in 1992, in 1993 and again in 2011. The deal was simple. The share of seats a party gets in Parliament should match the share of party votes it wins. This year that deal has been bent further out of shape than at any time since MMP began.
Preliminary results from the 7 November election show an overhang of 11 seats, pushing the House from its usual 120 members to 131, according to reporting summarised by Newswire on 18 November. RNZ's Russell Palmer reported the same day that seven of those extra seats belong to National and four to Te Pāti Māori. The official result is due on 27 November, after special votes are counted, so the exact numbers may still move. But the shape of the problem will not.
What the experts are saying
On 18 November, 46 legal, political and public policy experts published an open letter called "Keep the 'P' in MMP". It was led by Otago University law professor Andrew Geddis, political scientist Lara Greaves and researcher Max Rashbrooke, Stuff and RNZ reported. Their message was that the overhang now puts the proportionality of the whole system at risk, and that politicians must act before the next election.
Geddis described the current outcome, Newswire reported, as "Not really the way democracy is supposed to work". He also noted the clock is ticking: there are only three years before New Zealanders vote again.
The experts are careful not to blame only one side. As RNZ reported, Geddis said Te Pāti Māori's overhang came from a deliberate strategy of winning electorates while collecting few party votes, while National's was more of an organic result of holding many electorate seats as its party vote fell. The Spinoff's figures, cited by Newswire, show National won 42 electorates on a party vote that would have entitled it to about 35 seats, while Te Pāti Māori won five of the seven Māori seats with well under one per cent of the party vote.
Rashbrooke warned that, unless the rules change, parties could start engineering overhangs on purpose, turning future elections into an arms race of split-vote tactics. That is the real danger. Once one party benefits from gaming the system, every party is under pressure to copy it, and voters lose the clear link between how they vote and who governs.
Why this matters for fairness
Overhangs are not new. Newswire notes they followed the 2005, 2008, 2011, 2014 and 2023 elections. But they used to be one or two seats. An 11-seat overhang is different in kind. In a close election it can decide which bloc governs, even when the other bloc won more party votes.
The experts themselves drew the comparison with 1978 and 1981, RNZ reported, when National kept power under first-past-the-post despite Labour winning more votes. MMP was supposed to end that kind of result. It would be a bitter irony if MMP slowly drifted back towards it.
This is not about which party wins this particular count. A fair rule should be one you would accept whether it helps you or hurts you. That is exactly why Labour, the Greens and The Opportunity Party should champion it now, while the next government is still being formed.
The fix was recommended in 2012
None of this is a surprise. After the 2011 referendum kept MMP, the Electoral Commission reviewed the system and recommended in 2012 that overhang seats be abolished, as RNZ and Newswire both reported. Governments led by both National and Labour have since changed electoral law without acting on it. Labour should own its share of that failure, and then fix it.
The experts' letter sets out five options. Parliament could add list seats so the House grows to restore proportion; reduce the number of electorates; remove extra electorate seats from parties that win more than their party-vote share, as Germany now does, perhaps allowing one or two overhang seats; move to a single vote that counts for both electorate and party; or weight MPs' votes in the House by party-vote share. Each has costs. Geddis has said plainly that there is no perfect electoral system.
The German-style option is worth serious attention. It keeps the principle that party vote decides the size of each party's caucus, while still letting electorates choose a local MP. It would also take away the incentive to game the system.
The other side
National's position, as reported by The Spinoff and summarised by Newswire, is that the usual post-election review by the Electoral Commission and Parliament's Justice Committee is enough. ACT's David Seymour has said voters are entitled to use their two votes however they choose, and that is a fair point about voter freedom. Earlier this year Christopher Luxon said National would hold a referendum on MMP itself if re-elected, an idea NZ First, ACT, Labour and the Greens all opposed. Labour's Kieran McAnulty has warned that overhang tactics are likely to become permanent unless the rules change.
Those are real arguments, and they deserve a hearing. But a routine review that ends in a report on a shelf is how the 2012 recommendation was lost. And a referendum on scrapping MMP would be the wrong answer to a problem that can be fixed inside MMP.
What the next government should do
The experts want a dedicated select committee to work through the options quickly. That is the minimum. Labour, the Greens and Opportunity should go further and write a firm commitment into any coalition or confidence agreement: a cross-party process that reports within a year, followed by legislation in time for 2029.
They should also invite National, ACT, NZ First and Te Pāti Māori into that process. Electoral law works best when it is built across the aisle, so that the next change of government does not simply reverse it. Every party should sign up to one principle: no party should get more seats than its share of the party vote earns it.
Opportunity in particular has an opening here. A party that campaigns on evidence-based reform could make fixing the overhang one of its price-of-support items, whichever way it leans. Labour and the Greens should welcome that and back it.
The last word
MMP has served New Zealand well because voters trust that it is fair. That trust is earned one election at a time. An 11-seat overhang tells us the system has a hole in it, and that parties are learning how to drive through it.
The next government has three years to close that hole. If it waits for another review, it will have chosen to run the 2029 election on rules everyone already knows are broken.
This is an opinion column.
Sources: RNZ (Russell Palmer), "Experts call for urgent MMP reform over election overhang", 18 November 2026, as republished by Farmers Weekly; Stuff (Emma Ricketts), "46 electoral experts sign open letter calling for MMP reform", 18 November 2026; Newswire, "46 experts urge New Zealand politicians to fix the MMP overhang as Parliament grows to 131 seats", 18 November 2026; Electoral Commission, Review of the MMP voting system, 2012.
Photo: public-domain photograph via Wikimedia Commons (public domain / CC0), selected by Downunder Voices.
About this report
This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.
Join our community
Follow Downunder Voices
Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.



