17 November 2026
Opinion: Record KiwiSaver hardship withdrawals are a warning light. The next government must fund the people who help families out of debt
More than 52,000 New Zealanders raided their retirement savings for hardship in a single year. The answer is not to lock the door on them but to properly fund free financial mentors and deal with the jobs crisis behind the numbers.
Downunder Voices perspective
Full analysis
When people start emptying their retirement savings just to get through the week, something has gone badly wrong. In New Zealand that is now happening on a scale we have never seen.
In the year to June 2026, 52,330 KiwiSaver members made a financial hardship withdrawal, according to Inland Revenue statistics updated on 19 October. Ten years earlier, in the 2016 financial year, the figure was 10,670. Hardship applications now outnumber first-home applications, according to new university research.
The dollar figures tell the same story. Hardship withdrawals reached $443.6 million in the year to 31 March 2025, up from $264.3 million the year before, a rise of 50.8 per cent, Victoria University of Wellington law lecturer Victoria Stace wrote in research published by 1News and The Conversation on 17 November. One KiwiSaver provider told her research team that withdrawals were "roughly three times what we had pre-Covid".
These are not people cashing in for a holiday. To get a hardship withdrawal you have to show you cannot meet basic living costs. Every one of those 52,000 applications is a household that has run out of other options.
Why this is happening
The obvious place to start is jobs. New Zealand's unemployment rate rose to 5.7 per cent in the September 2026 quarter, the highest in more than a decade, interest.co.nz reported on 4 November from Stats NZ figures. About 174,000 people were out of work. Annual wage growth slowed to 2.1 per cent.
That is the economy the National-led government has presided over for three years. Its answer to a slowing economy was to cut public spending hard and wait for the private sector to pick up the slack. For tens of thousands of families, the slack has instead been picked up by their own retirement savings.
Every dollar taken out now is a dollar, plus decades of compound growth, that will not be there at 65. Today's hardship becomes tomorrow's poverty in old age, and eventually a cost the rest of us share through the pension and the welfare system.
The people doing the hard work
There is a group of New Zealanders who see this up close every day: financial mentors, the mostly community-based workers who help people with debt for free. Many are volunteers.
Their umbrella body, FinCap, told Parliament's Social Services and Community Committee in May that mentors closed 30,000 financial hardship cases in 2025, a 57 per cent increase since 2021. A FinCap survey found mentors now spend 40 per cent of their time on KiwiSaver hardship applications.
That second figure should alarm any government. It means that a large share of the country's free debt-help workforce has been turned into a paperwork service for retirement withdrawals, instead of doing what mentors do best: negotiating with creditors, sorting out benefit entitlements and, where needed, helping people through formal insolvency so that the debt stops growing.
FinCap has put a price on fixing this. In March it identified a $30.5 million funding gap and called for total sector funding of $50 million, with $25 million to come from the industries that benefit when their customers get help, such as banks, lenders, KiwiSaver providers, power companies and telcos. It described mentoring as a "fence at the top of the cliff".
What the research recommends
Dr Stace's research, commissioned by FinCap, makes four sensible proposals. Anyone applying for a hardship withdrawal should be offered a session with a financial mentor first. There should be a central hardship assessment and support service, so people are not dealing with very different forms and rules depending on which provider they happen to be with. The government should look at trialling "sidecar" emergency savings accounts linked to KiwiSaver. And Inland Revenue and the Retirement Commission should work with providers to collect better data and standardise the process.
None of these ideas is expensive. All of them would keep more money in people's retirement accounts while still helping them when they are in trouble.
What the parties are offering
KiwiSaver reform is already on the table in the coalition talks. A National-led government would likely make KiwiSaver contributions compulsory, Dr Stace noted. Labour has promised compulsory employer contributions. The Opportunity Party's "KiwiSaver 2.0" plan includes a compulsory scheme with no hardship withdrawals at all, she wrote.
Labour's approach is the right foundation. Making employers contribute for every worker lifts the savings of low-paid people without taking more out of pay packets that are already stretched.
The Opportunity Party is right that hardship withdrawals are a poor substitute for a proper safety net, and its focus on long-term savings deserves a serious hearing in any negotiation. But simply banning hardship withdrawals, without first building something better, would leave desperate families with nowhere to turn except high-interest lenders. The sensible order is to build the support first, and then tighten the rules.
The Greens' long-standing call for a guaranteed minimum income points in the right direction. If benefits and support payments covered basic costs, far fewer people would need to break open their retirement savings in the first place.
A practical plan for the next government
Whoever forms the next government after the official results on 27 November should do four things in its first budget.
First, close FinCap's funding gap and require the industries that profit from lending and essential services to share the cost.
Second, put a financial mentor at the front door of every hardship application, as the research recommends.
Third, set up the central hardship service and standard rules across every KiwiSaver provider.
Fourth, and most importantly, treat rising unemployment as the emergency it is. Public investment in housing, infrastructure and training would put people back to work. That is the surest way to bring these withdrawal numbers down.
The other side
The government's supporters would argue that rising unemployment reflects high interest rates set to bring inflation down, and that a recovery is coming. They also point out that hardship withdrawals exist precisely so people can use their own money when they need it. Others argue that compulsory industry levies would raise costs that are passed on to customers, and that mentoring services should be funded through normal budget decisions rather than new charges.
Those are fair points, but they do not change the basic picture. More than 52,000 New Zealanders took money out of their retirement savings last year because they could not pay for the basics. A government that is serious about both today's cost of living and tomorrow's retirements should be helping them before they reach that point.
This is an opinion column.
Sources: Inland Revenue, KiwiSaver withdrawal statistics by number, updated 19 October 2026; Victoria Stace for The Conversation, republished by 1News, 17 November 2026; interest.co.nz (Mandy Te), Stats NZ September quarter labour market figures, 4 November 2026; FinCap, "Social Services and Community Committee hear our request for funding", 18 May 2026; FinCap, "Call for industry co-funding to support essential financial mentors", 25 March 2026.
Photo: public-domain photograph via Wikimedia Commons (public domain / CC0), selected by Downunder Voices.
About this report
This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.
Join our community
Follow Downunder Voices
Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.

