12 November 2026
Opinion: The new dairy welfare code dropped winter grazing and shelter rules, and they should be put back
The dairy cattle code issued in September left out proposed standards on intensive winter grazing and shelter after a contested process. The best farmers already do better, and the rules should reflect that.
Downunder Voices perspective
Full analysis
New Zealand sells its dairy products to the world on a promise: grass-fed cows, open pastures and high standards. A new code of welfare for dairy cattle was supposed to back that promise with clear minimum rules. On some important issues it does. On others, the protections that were consulted on simply disappeared. This column argues that the next government, ideally one led by Labour with the Greens and The Opportunity Party, should finish the job.
What the code does
The government announced the new code on 23 September. Acting Agriculture Minister Nicola Grigg said calves must be fed milk or milk replacer at least twice a day for their first two weeks, the minimum body condition score for milking cows will rise, thin cows will need a vet's approval before leaving the farm, and regulations to ban the tethering of dairy cattle will be developed. The code takes effect on 19 April 2027. Those are real improvements and deserve credit.
What was left out
RNZ reported on 30 September that several standards consulted on since 2022 were dropped from the final code. They included rules on intensive winter grazing, standards for transporting cull cows, and a requirement for farms to have a working relationship with a vet. National Animal Welfare Advisory Committee chair Matthew Stone said shade, shelter, calf rearing and pasture management during intensive winter grazing were among the most contested issues.
Winter grazing is the issue many New Zealanders will remember from images of cows standing in deep mud. Shelter and dry ground at calving remain only recommended best practice. SAFE chief executive Debra Ashton put the problem simply, telling RNZ: "how can you enforce good animal welfare when these are just recommendations?"
A process under a cloud
How the code was made matters too. B2B News reported on 12 November that associate agriculture minister Andrew Hoggard, a former Federated Farmers president, sent the draft back to the advisory committee in 2024 with a letter asking for "elevated consideration of economics and practicality". Hoggard was later seen to have a conflict of interest, and Grigg signed off the final code. Newsroom has since reported legal concerns: Animal Law Association president Marcelo Rodriguez Ferrere described the dairy and pig codes as "extremely vulnerable" to court challenge, according to the Democracy Project's summary of that report.
These are legal opinions, not court findings. But a code that may not survive a challenge gives farmers no certainty either.
What should happen next
Labour, the Greens and TOP should commit to revisiting the dropped standards through a clean, transparent process. That means restoring minimum rules on intensive winter grazing and shelter, consulting properly, and making sure no decision-maker has an industry conflict. It would protect animals, and it would protect the reputation that every dairy exporter relies on.
The other side
The outgoing government and farming groups argue the code is practical and workable. Grigg said "it's vital we maintain the confidence of New Zealanders and our overseas markets", and said the industry regards a higher body condition score as good practice. DairyNZ described it as the first major update in more than a decade, and Federated Farmers welcomed the changes, RNZ reported. The advisory committee chair said some proposals were scaled back because they did not meet the legal criteria in the Animal Welfare Act. Many farmers already invest heavily in good welfare and worry about costs piling up in a tough season.
Those concerns are real. But good farmers are already meeting higher standards on shelter and winter grazing. Writing those standards into the rules would reward them and bring everyone up to their level.
Sources: New Zealand Government press release (Hon Nicola Grigg) via Scoop, 23 September 2026; RNZ (Monique Steele), 30 September 2026, as published by the Otago Daily Times and Farmers Weekly; B2B News, 12 November 2026; The Democracy Project (Bryce Edwards), News Briefing, 12 November 2026, summarising Newsroom.
Photo: public-domain photograph via Wikimedia Commons (public domain / CC0), selected by Downunder Voices.
About this report
This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.
Join our community
Follow Downunder Voices
Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.


