Opinion: Selling Christchurch's fibre network for a one-off payday would be a mistake the city cannot undo
By Downunder Voices Opinion
This is opinion, not straight news. Prepared with AI assistance and published under our editorial standards.
Christchurch councillors decide on Wednesday whether to put the sale of Enable, worth up to $1 billion, to the public as their preferred option. A rates cap should not push the city into selling a profitable public asset.
Downunder Voices perspective
Full analysis
On Wednesday 25 November, Christchurch city councillors will decide whether selling Enable Networks, the city's fibre broadband company, becomes their preferred option for public consultation in the draft 2027 to 2037 long-term plan, Chris Lynch Media reported on 20 November. The case for selling is being made loudly. The case for keeping it deserves just as loud a hearing.
What is on the table
Enable was set up in 2007 and now operates as a regional broadband wholesaler. In the 2026 financial year it paid a $25 million dividend to Christchurch City Holdings, the council's investment arm, according to Chris Lynch Media. City Holdings has recommended selling its whole stake, while an independent review found a credible case both for keeping and for selling, and recommended the public be asked.
Finance committee chair Sam MacDonald backs a sale. He says it could raise about $1 billion, with roughly $500 million used to repay City Holdings debt and another $500 million placed in a professionally managed Future Fund. He estimates the council would borrow about $250 million less over a decade and save around $90 million in interest. "I want an iron fence around the Future Fund," he told Chris Lynch Media. The Press, as summarised by The Kākā on 20 November, reported that Deloitte valued Enable at $776 million as at 30 June.
The rates cap is doing the pushing
This debate does not come out of nowhere. The National-led government's proposed rates cap would limit council increases to between 2 and 4 per cent a year, the Otago Daily Times reported in December 2025. Christchurch's own modelling showed a 4 per cent cap would require rates in 2029/30 to be $80.3 million lower than planned. MacDonald told the ODT at the time: "I think the rates cap will help us have a conversation about Enable."
That is the problem in one sentence. A cap imposed from Wellington, without new funding for the infrastructure councils are expected to maintain, is steering cities towards selling the assets that earn them money. It is a short-term fix for a long-term squeeze.
Why keeping Enable is the better bet
First, a sale is permanent. Once a strategic network is sold, the city does not get it back, and future councils lose both the income and the say over how it is run. Fibre is not a luxury; it is the backbone that schools, small businesses, hospitals and people working from home now depend on.
Second, a promised "iron fence" is only as strong as the next council's vote. Future funds can be raided, rules can be rewritten, and a fund invested in markets rises and falls with them. An asset that has paid a steady dividend is not obviously worse than a pot of money whose protection depends on politicians not touching it.
Third, the public has spoken on this kind of question before. In the 2013 citizens-initiated referendum on central government asset sales, about two thirds of voters opposed selling shares in state power companies, according to the Electoral Commission's results. Labour and the Greens campaigned against those sales. The same principle applies locally: assets built with public money should not be sold to plug holes created by policy choices elsewhere.
Christchurch has also learned the value of what it owns. Mayor Phil Mauger has opposed selling Lyttelton Port, Orion and Christchurch Airport, the ODT reported. Enable belongs in the same category of long-term infrastructure, and People's Choice co-chair Paul McMahon was right to warn the ODT that chasing a sale is shortsighted.
The other side
Supporters of a sale make a serious argument. Paying down debt reduces interest costs, a Future Fund could spread returns across generations, and council chief executive Bede Carran has stressed that Wednesday's decision is about what to consult on, not a final call. Some councillors, such as Aaron Keown, say they would support a sale only if it stacks up financially. Those are reasonable positions, and the public should see the full numbers.
What councillors should do
Councillors should put both options to residents fairly, with independent figures on dividends, interest savings and the long-term value of the network. They should not present a sale as the preferred path simply because a rates cap makes the books harder to balance. And the incoming government in Wellington, whoever leads it, should rethink a rates cap that pushes councils to sell the family silver rather than giving them better ways to fund growth.
Christchurch rebuilt itself once. It should not now sell off one of the few modern assets it built for the long term.
This is an opinion column.
Sources: Chris Lynch Media (Kineta Knight), "Finance chair backs $1 billion Enable sale ahead of council debate", 20 November 2026; The Kākā (Bernard Hickey), "Early Bird", 20 November 2026, summarising The Press (Tina Law and Amber Allott), 20 November 2026; Otago Daily Times, "Could a rates cap mean asset sales?", 9 December 2025; Electoral Commission, 2013 citizens-initiated referendum results.
Photo: public-domain photograph via Wikimedia Commons (public domain / CC0), selected by Downunder Voices.
About this report
This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.
Join our community
Follow Downunder Voices
Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.
