● NZ ELECTION COUNT☀ WEATHER● RADIOAdvertise
DVDOWNUNDERVOICESAustralia · New Zealand · World
Back to Editorial
Editorial

13 November 2026

Opinion: Start phasing out bottom trawling now and give our seabed a chance to recover

By Downunder Voices Opinion

Opinion: Start phasing out bottom trawling now and give our seabed a chance to recover

The Opportunity Party wants a phase-out of bottom trawling to begin straight away, starting with sensitive areas like the Hauraki Gulf. With so little of our ocean protected, the conservation case is strong, and a careful plan can look after fishing exports and port towns too.

Downunder Voices perspective

Full analysis

New Zealand likes to sell itself to the world as clean and green. Under the water, that promise is harder to keep. Bottom trawling, which drags heavy nets across the seafloor, still brings in most of the fish caught in our waters. After this month's election, the question of whether to phase it out has moved from the margins to the negotiating table.

This column backs a phase-out. The Opportunity Party (TOP) has made it one of its five bottom lines, and Labour leader Chris Hipkins has signalled he is open to it. A Labour-led government, working with the Greens and TOP, should make it happen, carefully and with the industry, but starting now.

What is on the table

TOP set out its bottom lines in September. According to 1News on 29 September, one is that the next government must begin phasing out bottom trawling immediately, working with industry, iwi and coastal communities. Party leader Qiulae Wong argued that bottom trawling cannot be squared with healthy oceans. RNZ reported on 8 October that TOP wants an end to the practice in sensitive areas, including the Hauraki Gulf, first, followed by a progressive phase-out elsewhere.

TOP's own policy page says New Zealand has the fifth-largest ocean territory on earth, yet only about 0.5% of it is protected as marine reserve. It wants 30% protected by 2035, cameras on commercial fishing boats and an ecosystem-based approach to quota. It also points out that three companies control about 60% of fishing quota. Those are party figures, but they frame the choice well: this is a public resource, and the public is entitled to a say in how it is managed.

Why it matters now

The provisional results give National, ACT and NZ First 67 seats, with special votes still to be counted and the final result due on 27 November, 1News reported on 10 November. TOP holds seven seats. Ms Wong met Christopher Luxon on 9 November and Mr Hipkins the following day. Whoever governs may need TOP, so its ocean policy is now part of the deal-making.

At a televised leaders' debate before the election, Mr Hipkins answered yes when asked about phasing in a ban, RNZ reported. Since the election he has said his concern is mainly about method. "It all comes down to a question of how," he told The Spinoff on 10 November. That is the right question, and it has good answers: start with the most fragile places, set a clear timetable, fund new gear and training, and back the workers and port towns that depend on fishing.

The other side

The industry's concerns are real and should be stated plainly. Moana New Zealand chief executive Steve Tarrant told RNZ that about 70% of the volume caught in New Zealand comes from bottom trawling, and called a blanket ban irresponsible. Sealord chief executive Doug Paulin described the policy as populist and said no other technique can catch those species economically. Mr Luxon said he was "open to" a phase-in, but stressed the need to balance it against the two billion dollars and 9000 jobs he linked to the practice. Even Greenpeace, RNZ reported, favours a phased, targeted ban on the most damaged areas rather than an immediate nationwide one.

Those points argue for doing this well, not for doing nothing. A phase-out with a timetable gives companies time to change boats and methods. Starting with sensitive places like the Hauraki Gulf protects the areas that matter most while the rest of the plan is worked out.

The bottom line

A seabed scraped bare does not grow back in an election cycle. Protecting it is a long-term investment in fish stocks, in the communities that catch them and in the reputation that sells New Zealand seafood overseas. Labour, the Greens and TOP should agree on a sensible, staged plan and get on with it.

Sources: 1News, 29 September 2026; RNZ (Felix Walton) via Otago Daily Times, 8 October 2026; The Opportunity Party, Healthy Oceans policy (accessed 14 November 2026); 1News, 10 November 2026; The Spinoff (Lyric Waiwiri-Smith), 10 November 2026.

Photo: public-domain photograph via Wikimedia Commons (public domain / CC0), selected by Downunder Voices.

About this report

This article contains independently written commentary and community perspective from Downunder Voices.

Join our community

Follow Downunder Voices

Join thousands of readers following news and community stories from Australia, New Zealand and the Pacific.

Read Next

View latest
Source: The Loadstar

17 November 2026

Gemini carriers target complete return to Suez transits by mid-January

Gemini Cooperation partners Maersk and Hapag-Lloyd will have made a full resumption of Suez transits on their Asia-Europe services by mid-January. Yesterday, the partners outlined the schedule for the last three Asia-North Europe services still detouring via the Cape of Good Hope to return to the Red Sea routing. The Asia-Northern Europe Loop 1 (Maersk AE2/Hapag-Lloyd NE1) will resume Suez transits in both directions with the departure of the 18,300 teu Mary ...

The LoadstarRead original
NZ Election: special votes being counted — result 27 Nov